Yeah, that is definitely a good summary, I agree with you both.
I think it's just (for me) because vinyls represent a time when hard copies meant the most, especially with the art and such. And it's true, more and more new vinyls are offering free digital downloads, so it makes the vinyl twice as awesome.
Plus, I just have this natural tendency to balk whatever more than 70% of the population is doing at any given time...if anything, the digital push has brought me toward vinyl more. Of course, digital has clearly brough me into a lot more new music, too...but let's not bring this debate all the way there. It's the holidays for goodness sakes.